Due to the tons of pictures and my descriptions, I decided to put this behind a cut. Grab a warm apple/pumpkin cider, a sticky tricky treat, and enjoy!
Eastern Plaguelands' Plagued Trees
Cannibalistic Scarlet Judge
When crossing the bridge from Eastern Plaguelands to Western Plaguelands, if you're lucky this rare spawn may be up. How did he survive in the wilderness this long? Engage him and see how he's clearly gone mad; "I Judge you... delicious!"
Hanging people in Tirisfal Glades
The Lost of Lordaeron
Hillsbrad's Human Seedlings
|Picture from WoWwiki|
The Bushes Have Eyes!
Gnoll Tents made of Humans
Oh those crafty Gnolls! You'd think after all this time they would have found another source of skin to make tents out of. Pretty gross! *shivers*
Along the mountains of Azshara live the huge Cliff Giants. I guess you can say they eat whatever they find, and these two poor victims became one of the giant's meals. Clicking on the poor frozen victims allows you to loot the Crystallized Note. (Horde version | Alliance version)
Felwood's Poisoned Trees
The Dead Goliaths
The Shady Rest Inn
Once a popular inn at the entrance to Dustwallow Marsh, The Shady Rest has an extremely shady past. Eventually, the place was burnt to the ground by the Grimtotem Clan. The poor Innkeeper, James Hyal, lost his wife and child to the fire. This left him very distraught and unstable. If you look around, it seems that a few other patrons may have lost their life to other things instead of the fire that night.
Challe's Home for Little Tykes
Tucked away on one of the hills around Nagrand, these lives a troll woman by the name of Challe. Her tiny home is accompanied by many children of all different races. While this all seems innocent, a trip to the back of her house may show a darker side to Challe. There are cages with skeletons inside. Some people speculate she's not taking care of the children but instead, raising them to eat! This could be an homage to the Tale of Baba Yaga.
The Weeping Quarry
Rona Greenteeth's Fine Cuisine
The Darkmoon Faire is already a place of mystery and wonder. If you walk into the woods you're going to meet an Undead woman way off to the coast. She offers a variety of food to the weary traveler. Let's just say her tastes in food might not be exactly what you're looking for.
There are a few places I didn't include because I'm doing stuff strictly dedicated to them. I also didn't include Pandaria in this list because I really didn't find anything there creepy except for the Sha. I would love to hear if you found something that you find creepy there or in any of the other zones. Let me know in the comments below!